True sis’ first kiss

Spoiler alert. On two recent occasions, namely Frozen and Maleficent, the makers of Disney have diverted our notion of true love from ‘protective prince charming’ to ‘protective loving sister’. Are those attempts to break with an age-old tradition?

Let’s face it: ever since Disney’s feature-length movies arose, most of them ended with a wedding. Sure, there have been exceptions. Dumbo liberated himself from the public opinion and the Fox and the Hound painfully discovered how predisposed societal roles can divide friends, but generally, Disney’s protagonists have lived happily ever after.

You’re not an outcast anymore if you state that Disney has tricked generations into the ideal of getting married by highlighting only the exiting road towards the encounter with the other half. Perhaps the writers of these films have sensed this critique. Maybe they agreed with it. Of course, Pixar winked at this given with the Shrek sequels, where the trails and tribulations of marriage came up, but even that didn’t truly address the decreasing interest for being together in general.

In a society where individuality is more pronounced than ever and romances fail over and over again, it was about time that the film industry came up with better plots than the eternal story of romance. Emphasizing the powerful bond between women may well have been the wisest thing to do. If you look at the amount of sisterselfies that flows by on Facebook and Instagram, you would surely buy the idea that sisterhood is the new societal ideal.

The only way to face this, guys, is if we form a warm global collective of loving brothers. But let’s not fool ourselves: people are far more likely to look at our pictures when they have a girl on them, so the battle is already lost. Besides, we western men are far too independent to define our image by pictures of our fellows. We are slayers, and slayers work alone.

Which raises another point: have you ever seen a Disney tale where a man is promised redemption after ‘true love’s first kiss?’ Men are free by definition. They have to turn the force of evil to liberate the woman and earn her love. They could rescue any other woman if they wanted to, but they happen to have chosen the female protagonist. Therefore, ending a Disney film with a curse-lifting brother’s kiss would be less credible, and probably feel less liberating than these recent girly storlyline twists. By letting women save women, Disney answers to a growing independance. In this story, men are perhaps less usefull, but as free as ever.

I still don’t know a single Disney film where the princess rescues the prince. Wouldn’t that be laughable?

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “True sis’ first kiss”

  1. Great thoughts.
    “men are perhaps less useful, but as free as ever” – I like that. Although I think men are enslaved these days more than ever to mortgages, advertising, and other modern society garbage – or at least they believe they are enslaved.
    I don’t watch Disney but maybe “Brave” came closest to girl being brave – but she has no prince. The little mermaid saved the prince from drowning only to sacrifice herself…
    Being less useful is not a positive thing in my opinion, but I am old fashioned. 🙂

    1. Hi Beehappy! Yes, Brave fits in the recent trend. I didn’t mention it, because it doesn’t have this true love’s kiss, but again, it’s the girl saving the girl (daughter mother this time). As for the little mermaid, yes, she saved the prince, but the prince murdered Ursula.

      I agree about the less usefulness not being positive. It’s even dangerous. People might get strange ideas. But that’s another story. I usually mean my writing with a flavour of irony.

  2. excellent and well said. when I watched frozen with both my SON’S for the first of many times…It was a serious teachable moment…long way to go but baby steps count.

  3. Thanks for your great post – it made me reflect things I’ve red before. For example G.K.Chesterton has said like this: Romanticism is the deepest thing about life – it goes deeper than reality. Maybe we all have learned that from life ourselves? The need for romantic love is deep inside the human heart. The writers John Eldredge and Brent Curtis have written a marvelous book called “The sacred romance”, from Christian point of view. They say that in Christian life it is all question about a love story of one’s heart. The greatest romantic scriptwriter of all times is God: The Bible begins and ends in a Wedding! So it is no wonder, that the Wedding theme is so common in movies, too.

  4. I’m with until the last sentence. Instead of laughable, wouldn’t it be grand? And wouldn’t it also be grand to see the male/female relationship depicted as something more nuanced and complex?

  5. Great blog 🙂 But.. did you think of Pocahontas? She saves the life of her lover in the end of the movie. And they don’t get married, but he leaves her heartbroken while he goes back to England… Disneymovies can be so cruel sometimes

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s